Lost in Translation—Deciphering Builders’ Insurance


Learning the language of insurance

Many years ago, when I was a new agent, I would often cry myself to sleep. Learning insurance is like learning a foreign language. If you don’t understand the language, you and your clients could be in a world of hurt.

This is my chosen profession; I love insurance (I know, I am a crazy person, but I do). Persevering through the learning curve is what we all do when we love something. However, I’m completely empathetic to how most people feel about insurance. For most people, insurance is never going to be something they love. At best, it is something they tolerate. It’s an expensive bill every year for a product that they most likely will never use and never really understand.

After a decade in the business, I noticed that I was getting asked the same questions. It occurred to me that most people have the same concerns. I started writing answers to questions that I knew my clients would inevitably have.

RELATED: Warranty Woes for Frustrated Builders

My disclaimer is that no insurance policy is one-size-fits-all. Everybody’s business, tolerance to risk and comfort level may be different. Another insurance agent may answer these questions in a different way, but after 10 years insuring the building community, I feel I am a pretty good interpreter when it comes to the language of insurance.

Question: I am a builder and I don’t have any employees. Why would I carry workers’ compensation?

Answer: There are a lot of reasons why builders who do not have employees should carry workers’ compensation.

  1. Although you may have health insurance, some insurance carriers exclude injuries on the jobsite. Check your personal policy to make sure you have coverage.
  2. Nowadays, everyone is an “independent contractor.” Let’s be honest—somebody must be the laborer. If that person gets injured, or worse, it always rolls up the hierarchy of the job. If you are flying “insurance commando,” you could be paying a lot of money if you get sued.
  3. Just because someone gets paid as an independent contractor does not necessarily make them one in the eyes of the law. Visit colorado.gov/pacific/cdle/independent-contractors to learn who the Colorado Department of Labor and Employment considers an independent contractor.

Question: I am very confused about WRAP/OCIP policies. For example, when and where should I use them? Why can’t my general liability cover me for smaller projects when we are building under 10 townhomes? Why are these policies so expensive?

Answer: These are all good questions. Let’s break it down. A WRAP policy, also known as an owner-controlled insurance policy, is designed to cover the whole project and everyone working on the project. It usually excludes the professional services for E&O, but many WRAPs will now cover the professional services for bodily injury and property damage to a third-party for an additional premium.

Many general liability policies may cover a builder for a smaller attached project, like rowhomes, but the issue becomes the subcontractors’ insurance. Often, those policies have multifamily exclusions or limits on how many projects or attached homes they can work on within a year.

Most builders don’t know what to look for or have the time to comb through each subcontractor’s policy looking for these exclusions or endorsements.

The other concern is that some smaller subcontractors are notorious for cancelling their policies after a job is finished. This could mean no coverage at the time of an occurrence. Many builders and developers like WRAP policies because it is a one-time payment for a policy that will cover everyone through the statute of repose, hence the big price tag.

The other reason the cost of these policies starts to add up is that carriers frequently require additional risk management products. For example, they often want the builder to use a third-party risk management company to oversee the project. They could require a 10-2 structural warranty, peer reviews and much more. These additional requirements will add to the cost.

Question: One of my projects was recently vandalized. When I put in a claim to my general liability provider, I was surprised to learn that I had no coverage. I was told I needed a builder’s risk policy. What is a builder’s risk policy, and why doesn’t my general liability cover me?

Answer: So many builders think that property damage to “your” property is covered under their general liability. General liability protects against third-party claims for bodily injury, property damage or advertising injury (slander). Builder’s risk policies, commonly known as “course of construction” insurance, are for the property during the building period. Builder’s risk covers the structure, as well as materials on site, in transit and off site. There are often soft costs included as well. Builder’s risk policies are not created equal so make sure you go over the coverage forms with your agent.

Question: I am a small home builder with only four employees. We are so busy building that we often forget to collect certificates. We always seem to be scrambling at audit time to go back and collect the certificates. When I think about my subcontractors and their insurance, or lack thereof, I get very stressed out. How do I know if my subcontractors are giving me the right insurance or are covered correctly? What if they cancel their coverage after the job is over?

Answer: Handling subcontractors’ insurance is probably the most stressful thing a builder must do. You are not just asking for a certificate; you also need to know if there are exclusions on your subs’ policies that could come back to bite you. For example, is there a new residential home exclusion? Soil movement exclusion? Multifamily exclusions? Have their limits been diminished due to a previous claim?

If it is too hard to collect the certificates on time, it is almost impossible to actually check the insurance and make sure the coverages are there. One way to help minimize your risk is to enlist a great team of insurance agents and attorneys who specialize in the construction industry. Your attorney will write out a subcontractor agreement outlining the insurance requirements. Your insurance agent can educate you on what to look for. You could use a third-party certificate tracking program to assist you. At the end of the day, the responsibility is solely yours.

As for subcontractors canceling their insurance after a job is finished, let’s be honest—these are not the professional subcontractors you should be working with. Build a team of well-respected subcontractors, pay them well and on time, and audit their insurance regularly.

Question: I recently had my workers’ compensation and general liability audit. I was shocked at how much I ended up owing. Although I received the paperwork, I didn’t fully understand how my provider calculated the additional premium. What would make my premium so far off from what I estimated at the beginning of the year?

Answer: There are many factors that are considered when auditing policies. Insurance carriers look at payroll, gross revenue, sub costs and additional exposures, to name a few.

Another thing that can make your premium increase at audit is not having all your certificates of insurance for your subcontractors. If you cannot present certificates for your subcontractors, the auditor will classify them as uninsured subs. Depending on the type of work they performed, you would be given a rate—the higher the risk, the higher the rate.

As for workers’ compensation, Pinnacol Assurance is enforcing their Declaration of Independent Contractor status forms. What that means is that every independent contractor that does not carry workers’ compensation has to be pre-approved through Pinnacol. If they are not approved prior, expect to pay an additional premium for that subcontractor. Go to Pinnacol Assurance to learn more.

We all like to play the “Will I be covered for this? Will I be covered for that?” game. At the end of the day, no one will ever be 100% protected. Every policy has something in it that could potentially be a risk. That is why we have to surround ourselves with the most knowledgeable partners, people who are truly invested in our success. We may not be fluent in the language of insurance, but we need to at least have a basic understanding of our coverages and partner with a great insurance interpreter.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Preparing for Emergency Calls

In our world of third-party warranty management, we have a definitive list of emergency calls that qualify to dispatch a subcontractor.

3D Home Printing Company Moves to Greeley

Alquist 3D, which built the first 3D printed home in the nation, moved to Greeley, thanks to incentives from the city and the state.

Essential Workwear for Construction Professionals

Construction apparel can not only maximize comfort and performance but also help keep workers safe while on the job.

Related articles

Preparing for Emergency Calls

In our world of third-party warranty management, we have a definitive list of emergency calls that qualify to dispatch a subcontractor.

Balancing Insurance, Contracts and Warranties with Professional Support

Constructing a home is an intricate dance of quality assurance, contract management, insurance details and warranty guarantees.

Leveraging Drone Technology to Manage Risk

Is drone technology a tool that can provide missing evidence for builders to defend themselves against construction defect claims?

The Insurance Risk of Not Embracing Technology

By embracing innovative tools, builders can transform their operations and protect their businesses from potential claims.